jump to navigation

Calling Myself Out July 1, 2010

Posted by Jarrah H in Can-Con, feminism, Politics.
Tags: , , , , , ,

Lately I’ve been conflicted about something I posted on this blog a little less than a month ago.

Earlier this year I started posting funny YouTube clips on Fridays, including this clip from This Hour has 22 Minutes about John Baird:

We had been talking about John Baird that week and criticizing his overly aggressive style in the House of Commons, so when I saw the video I thought it was funny and apt.

The thing is, a couple months before, a commenter had let us know about this picture of Helena Guergis, and I was really offended, even though I’m not a fan of Guergis, nor the Toronto Sun.

I didn’t write it on the blog but I saw the Toronto Sun cover as comparing women to dogs in a demeaning and dehumanizing way. As much as I think Guergis’ actions were seriously sketchy, I don’t think it’s cool to put her face next to a dog’s and say they’re the same thing.

So given that, I’m feeling like it might’ve been a bit hypocritical of me to go around promoting the video comparing John Baird to a dog.

On the one hand, a satirical sketch by a group like like This Hour Has 22 Minutes is clearly not meant to be taken too seriously, whereas the front cover of a newspaper at least has the pretense of being objective media. One was intended to be a joke, and one wasn’t, so you could argue they’d also have different impacts.

You could also argue that there’s a long history of comparing women to animals in order to maintain gender hierarchy (e.g. calling women “bitch”, “chick”, comparing them to “meat”, etc.). That could mean that such comparisons about Helena Guergis would be more damaging and oppressive than against John Baird.

On the other hand, that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s great to go around comparing men to dogs or other animals. So I’m calling myself out on that one but I’d also be interested to hear what you think: are these types of comparisons always bad, or just in certain contexts, or just when applied to women, or should we just see them as a joke and forget about it?



Bookmark and Share



1. Zoe Li - July 1, 2010

Jarrah, your post made me laugh. You call yourself out then wonder whether it was warranted. Plus the dogs just kill me. I suggest considering ‘calling yourself out’ a talent. Not everyone can do it or do it well.

So funny and appropriate that you post this on Canada Day.

2. jarrahpenguin - July 2, 2010

Aw, thanks Zoe. Your comment definitely made me laugh too – you’re right it was a pretty Canadian thing to do to be worrying about offending people like that 🙂

3. Carla - July 5, 2010

Huh. Interesting. I don’t know. I kinda think you’re making a bigger deal than it needs to be. Like you said: one was a joke and one wasn’t. But I guess it is a little hypocritical…

4. cna training - July 8, 2010

nice post. thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: